Should you press the button when pulling the handbrake or not?

The argument of the button-pressers is that you will wear the teeth of the ratchet down by not pressing the button. Sounds possible, which is why so many people believe it. Which is a pity because it’s wrong. You should not press the button when pulling the handbrake.

Arno

08 Mar 2016

To understand this we’ll take a look at how the thing works.

The handbrake pivots around a pin and pulls on a cable which is connected to the brake calipers. To lock the handbrake in place when pulled up there’s a ratchet mechanism consisting of a bracket with teeth and a pawl. This pawl is connected via a push rod to the release button. Behind the release button there’s a spring. To make the pawl lock between the teeth of the ratchet bracket it has to be pushed against this bracket. This is done by the spring behind the button. This spring forces the button outwars, pulling on the rod which in turn makes the pawl pivot around a pin, forcing it between the teeth of the ratchet bracket.

In the picture above you see the ratchet bracket. It’s a picture I found on Google of a handbrake mechanism from an old Merc. As you can see the teeth are a little worn. But this shouldn’t be a problem, because the pawl locks between the teeth and not on the top of the teeth. As long as the majority of the tooth is still there the mechanism will lock, provided there’s enough force forcing the pawl into the teeth. And this is where the problem lies.

The return spring behind the release button is the real culprit. When handbrakes don’t lock anymore people immediately think of the ratchet. But in most cases it’s this spring that’s causing the problems.

When a changing force acts on metal you get fatigue. The metal litteraly gets tired and will deform pretty easily. A spring is based on metal’s resistance to deforming. But when the metal is fatigued there’s less resistance to deforming and the spring will lose some, of it’s compression. If this happens less force is forcing the pawl between the teeth of the ratchet bracket and the mechanism will start failing to lock. It will start to happen occasionaly but after a few months it will happen most of the time.

So now back to our original argument. What’s best, pushing or not pushing the button when you pull the handbrake? If we don’t want our mechanism to wear out we want to put as little force on the spring as possible, because big changes in force is what makes the spring wear out. From this we can conclude that you SHOULDN’T push the button when pulling the handbrake. You should let the ratchet mechanism do it’s work and use the button only when necessary (= to release the handbrake).

Think of it. If you push the button everytime you pull the handbrake you will cut the life of the return spring in half. It’ll take half as much time to wear the spring out than it would normally.

This content was originally posted by a Car Throttle user on our Community platform and was not commissioned or created by the CT editorial team.

Comments

Thank you. I was a confused child. Not knowing which road to take. Everything you say makes sense. Also with that noise people call annoying probably if they take their time and pull it up it wouldn’t be so bad for them.

it makes literally no difference if you do or dont press the button

I disagree, my handbrake on my GTI is kinda broken because the spring inside broke in two.

Tbh either way it’s minimal wear, you’re only pressing the button for a second every time you pull it, you make a convincing argument though

I don’t use the handbrake, i leave my car in it 1st gear. So my handbrake doesnt wear at all

Well, that doesn’t exactly work everywhere.

You realize the moment your tranny were to fail for some odd reason your car is free to roll away right?

Me too. I only use handbrake when I stop for couple minutes, when I don’t even bother to shut down the car.

I will sacrifice a single sodding spring for the sake of saving my wife’s life - saving her from me stabbing her to death for making that damn noise that’s the mechanical equivalent of dragging nails down the chalkboard of my nerves.

I really don’t see the problem with the sound. At leas in my cars it doesn’t sound irritating. It’s a confirmation the handbrake is on.

I drive a mercedes, your argument is invalid

I push my button when I pull my brake because I can’t stand the sound. If I have to replace the spring, I will. Lol

I really think I’m one of the few who doesn’t mind that sound. Everyone seems to complain about it, but I’ve never had a problem with it :/

Also I think the argument is BS in another way. The ratchet systems are DESIGNED to be ratcheted and are very durable. It’s silly to think that you are hurting the car by not pushing the button.

Exactly, but I felt this wouldn’t be enough to convince people. The fact that engineers design it like that has a reason. If you’d wear out the ratchet they wouldn’t put one in.

My car has an electronic park brake. Yep, carguys hate it. But at least I don’t have to worry about whether the button should be pressed or not :)

This is the reason why I will take out the return spring and put in a button. Cheap Drift mod. You wrote this down very good thanks for posting it. :))