7 Things I Learned After Living With A Mk7.5 Golf GTI For Two Months
1. Active Info Display isn't all that convincing
Probably the biggest change for the facelifted Golf is the new ‘Active Info Display’. It’s best thought of as VW’s version of Audi’s Virtual Cockpit, only it’s not as good.
I get that VW Group’s hierarchy means the posher Audi system can’t be dumped straight into a Golf, but Active Info Display feels very much like a poor relation, with much more basic functionality.
There’s so much that bugs me about it that I’ll be writing a whole post dedicated to my grievances, but to sum up, while Virtual Cockpit makes a good case for itself, it’s hard to see the benefit of Active Info Display over physical dials with a smaller trip computer LCD. Particularly when ours doesn’t let you have the map on both the centre screen and the instrument binnacle (although some versions will let you do that), nor zoom out the dials to any significant amount.
2. The GTI Performance is the one to have
Every time the front end of the GTI pushes wide (something which isn’t that hard to provoke) I feel a faint hint of disappointment. But it needn’t be that way: buy a GTI Performance, and you get VW Group’s mightily effective, understeer-killing VAQ front differential.
Not only that, but you get a cheeky 15bhp power boost to bring the total to a healthy 242bhp (not strictly necessary, but we’ll take it), bigger brakes, a bit of extra kit and - if you opt for an automatic Golf - the new seven-speed DSG as opposed to the older six-speed.
How much extra you pay depends on what gearbox/body style you go for, but for a five-door DSG like ours, you’re looking at an extra £1150. That’s a no brainer, surely?
3. It’s more economical than I expected
When we were running a DSG GTI Clubsport earlier this year, I struggled to get anything over 35mpg on a run. But despite the very small drop in power, the ‘boggo’ GTI has no trouble nudging 40mpg. Long-term economy currently sits at a healthy 33.9mpg.
4. I am starting to miss having a manual
While we’re on the subject of ‘our’ Clubsport, you might remember I wrote at the time that I wasn’t missing having a manual. Well, now I’m six and a bit months into our DSG-only Golf GTI journey, I am starting to miss stirring through a set of manually-engaged cogs.
The six-speed DSG is competent enough, but it has moments during multi-gear downshifts where it seems to sit and have a think for a good second (which can feel like an eternity) before finally slotting in a cog. From what we’ve seen the seven-speed is better - as you’d expect since it’s the newer box o’cogs - but it’s only fitted to the GTI Performance currently.
A manual just fits the car better, too. This is an uncomplicated hot hatch, and it needs an uncomplicated manual transmission to go with it, adding involvement and fun.
5. The Dynaudio sound system is great
In-car audio isn’t something I write about all that much, but it’s been on my mind more lately - partly inspired by disappointing showings from JLR’s weirdly flat Meridian systems, and a particularly naff Bose option in the new Nissan Qashqai.
Thankfully, there are no such issues with the Dynaudio ‘Excite’ system fitted to our GTI - it’s really rather good, with deep bass, a clear top end and a generally full sound. The eight-speaker, 400 watt system is a £550 option, but it’s worth it.
6. 19-inch wheels look great, but there's a catch
The whole point of buying a VW Golf GTI over something like a Honda Civic Type R or Ford Focus RS is it’s a more understated, relaxed beast. Your average GTI buyer will therefore probably want decent ride comfort, something which is slightly compromised on this Golf by the presence of 19-inch ‘Santiago’ wheels.
The two-tone, diamond-cut rims look awesome, but they bring with them an slightly crashy edge to the low-speed ride. They’re also not exactly cheap at £990 for the set, so you might better off spending that on another option, like that kick-ass Dynaudio stereo, or the Performance Pack.
7. 227bhp really is all you need on the road
There’s a school of thought that suggests cars with very little power are usually the most fun. I’m on board with that - an underpowered car can be given an absolute spanking with no fear of reaching antisocial speeds, after all. However, I’m starting to think that actually the 228bhp/261lb ft output of the GTI’s 2.0-litre inline-four is bang on the money for real-world fun.
It doesn’t feel slow even after stepping out of high-powered supercars, nor is it too fast: you can keep the throttle pinned for a reasonable amount of time without the fear of the local plod taking away your license and tearing it into tiny little pieces.
It helps that you have a fine chassis to exploit with that pokey four-pot this is a fun, capable car, and I’ve no doubt I’ll enjoy the rest of the test as much as I’ve enjoyed the first couple of month.
Comments
Is the next version going to be the Golf GTI 7.75
[DELETED]
And the version after that is going to be 7.775
And then there’s the US-only GT1.776
GTI (for car-guys): GreatTinglingInstinct
Rabbit approves!
“227bhp really is all you need”
.
Mercedes A45. We’re looking at you.
Also looking at the Golf R, Civic Type-R and Focus RS
A45 has almost double price in Israel MSRP: 391300 Israeli New Shekel ( equals110046.43 US Dollar)
I like the point here. The A45 sure is a silent beast, not to be underestimated. But the Golf R is cheaper and it growls like a terrier chasing the postman.
The Mk1 and Mk2 are the girl you loved in school and think back to, the mk3 was the ugly one night stand, the mk4 is the good looking girl but not much going on other wise, the mk5/6 is the girl you marry and the mk7 is the smart girl but is too clinical for any real feel or passion to form after you’ve had the others.
Pretty good explanation, especially mk1, 2 and 3.
I just picked up a 2018 Golf R and with regards to the active info display, i do not have any problems as mentioned in this article, i really like it. With regards to the DSG, i am so so so glad i went for the manual transmission, especially in 2017. The shift are short, i live in hilly Bavaria and lots of corners. So you can imagine the huge smile on my face rev matching and heal-toeing arounds bends from town to home, just a blast. Clutch is light and gear change is smooth, i do not regret it one bit. I went for the R over the GTi mainly because of the 4 motion, i kind of need it for an all weather, every day driving car in my area. The steep hills and curves coupled with snow, rain and sleet just adds more safety margin in the back of my head. So i can not comment on power or the ride, since in comfort mode with 19’ Pretoria’s it rides really well and smooth.
Congrats on the purchase! What option did you go for with the main screen? Ours is the ‘middle’ option which still has physical volume/zoom knobs, and on that it doesn’t allow you to have the map on both the centre screen an the binnacle. Which seems daft.
sure beats the subaru STI that thing isn’t as luxurious and understated as the Golf
I really wouldn’t, though…
RS isn’t the rival to the GTi - the Focus ST is. The Focus RS is a rival to the Golf R, and I’d rather have the Golf in both cases.
Unless you’re looking to just buy an investment - in which case buy the RS
Well, in all honesty I struggle to think of a moment when you’d need more than 7.227 hp…
7 hp is definitely all we need. And that extra .227 is perfect for over boost!
I have a 1.8t Jetta with 170hp is that good enough? yes its fast for a 4 cyl
I Current have a MK6 GTI manual. I bought it mid april this year. When i searched for GTI i wasent even considering the DSG, but then after the purchase i met a guy guy who had a GTD with DSG and i was blown away by how good it was. and now im second guessing the Manual. I sort off want to trade for a DSG. what are you guys opinion on the DSG and experience with it?
I love mine; I bought it since I live in metro Atlanta & bumper to bumper traffic would be hell (20 minutes for a quarter mile cause nobody can merge -_-). Its quick to respond if mash the pedal and the DSG “farts” are an interesting sound between shifts haha. Its a blast in tight turns with the paddles as you can control the car better with 2 hands then 1 (unless your Vin Diesel). Downsides include the fluid changes (pretty easy I’ve heard, about to do mine here in 20k) and you have to treat it like a manual. It does have clutch plates and not a torque converter; you can’t let it creep in traffic like you would an automatic. Lastly, the manual gearbox I believe is only good into the high 200s until upgrade vs the DSG which I believe is about 400hp before stage 1 gear upgrade (APR has a kit for 1200). I would touch on the TCU flashes but I currently have not tried one personally; that’ll be a later date after a new downpipe, CAI, and DSG servicing.
I currently run stock tune on both the TCU and ECU with just redtop coilpacks, new plugs, boost gauge, and a dogbone insert. Currently at 60xxx